FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION,
TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
CADDO TRIBE OF OKLAHOMA
Whereas, the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) is responsible for compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended (16 U.S.C. §470 et seq.) and implementing regulations (36 CFR Part 800); and
Whereas, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (16 U.S.C.§470 et seq.) provides definitions and procedures for consultation between federal agencies and Native American tribes for federal undertakings, as defined in 36 CFR §800.16(y); and
Whereas, the FHWA proposes to administer the Federal Aid Highway and transportation enhancement programs in Texas through the Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT) as authorized by 23 U.S.C. §101 et seq., 23 U.S.C. §133(d)(2) and 23 U.S.C. §315; and
Whereas, TxDOT employs professional staff capable of completing the Section 106 process on behalf of FHWA and has a record of successful compliance with Section 106; and
Whereas, FHWA has determined that federal-aid highway transportation projects it funds within the State of Texas are federal undertakings carried out by TxDOT; and
Whereas, the federal-aid highway transportation projects administered by TxDOT are carried out on non-federal and non-tribal land owned and controlled by the State of Texas and its political subdivisions; and
Whereas, the FHWA and TxDOT recognize that certain of those undertakings may have an effect upon historic properties included in or eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places and properties that contain Native American burials that require compliance with the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act ("NAGPRA," 25 U.S.C. §3001 et seq.) and its regulations (43 CFR Part 10); and
Whereas, the representatives of the FHWA and TxDOT have engaged in consultation with representatives of the Caddo Tribe of Oklahoma (hereafter, "the Tribe") to establish a Programmatic Consultation Process; and
Whereas, this Programmatic Consultation Process compliments the Programmatic Agreement executed by the FHWA, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the Texas State Historic Preservation Officer, and TxDOT for other aspects FHWA's compliance with Section 106; now
Therefore, the FHWA, TxDOT, and the Tribe do hereby agree to the following consultation process for federal-aid highway transportation projects in Texas:
- Agreement Period. This agreement becomes effective when fully executed by all parties hereto and shall remain in effect for five years. The agreement shall automatically renew at the end of each sequent five year period unless one or more of the parties expresses in writing to the other parties the need to revise the agreement.
- Federal Recognition. The Tribe is acknowledged by the Federal Government with a government-to-government relationship with the U.S. and is recognized as eligible for the special programs and services provided by the United States to Indians because of their status as Indians, and thus has status to establish a programmatic consultation process under 36 CFR §800.14(b).
- Consultation. FHWA grants TxDOT, using staff housed in the Environmental Affairs Division (TxDOT-ENV) who meet the Secretary of Interior's Professional Qualifications Standards (48 FR 44738-9), authority to fulfill FHWA's consultation requirements with the Tribe. FHWA shall approve the outcome of all consultations with the Tribe prior to its award of any assistance for undertakings under the Federal Aid Highway Program or other program involving FHWA assistance or approval.
- Point of Contact
- The FHWA points of contact for correspondence shall be Director, Planning & Program and Development and the Environmental Coordinator for Tribal Issues.
- The point of contact for correspondence to the State shall be the Supervisor of Archeological Studies, TxDOT, Environmental Affairs Division (TxDOT-ENV), for consultation on projects, determinations of eligibility, findings of effect, excavation plans, or NAGPRA-related matters.
- The point of contact for correspondence to the Tribe concerning federal undertakings shall be Robert Cast, and the Tribe's point of contact for NAGPRA shall be Bobby Gonzales. The Tribe shall direct all correspondence to the TxDOT-ENV point of contact.
- Each party shall notify the other parties in writing when the point of contact changes. Such changes shall not require amendment of this agreement.
- Area of Concern: TxDOT-ENV has consulted with the Tribe to establish the specific area of the state of Texas for which that tribe has concerns for historic properties. That area shall be known as the Area of Concern. The Area of Concern for the Tribe is shown in Attachment 1 to this agreement which is incorporated herein by reference.
- Project Specific Consultation: TxDOT-ENV shall consult with the Tribe as early as possible in project planning, environmental document development and design of project by:
The Tribe shall provide TxDOT-ENV with available verbal or documentary information that would assist TxDOT-ENV in determining when Native American sites may be affiliated with the Tribe's ancestral occupation of Texas.
- notifying the Tribe by letter of the following specific transportation projects that fall within their Area of Concern:
- all major projects on new location;
- all other projects where Native American sites have been identified; and/or
- where a site that can be culturally affiliated with the Tribe is identified in the area of potential effects of a proposed project that is outside of the Tribe's Area of Concern.
- notifying the Tribe by letter when a site identified within the Tribe's Area of Concern is believed to be affiliated with another federally-recognized tribe, providing the basis for that belief, and stating that future consultation will be confined to that other tribe unless the Tribe objects within 30 days of receipt of the letter.
- Timing. The Tribe shall be provided thirty (30) days from receipt of information in which to review and provide comments to TxDOT-ENV for a:
If the Tribe fails to comment within thirty (30) days of receipt of a request for review and comment, TxDOT-ENV and FHWA may proceed to the next step in the consultation process. Failure to comment will not prevent the Tribe from re-entering consultation at a later point. If the Tribe re-enters the consultation process, TxDOT-ENV and FHWA shall continue the consultation without being required to reconsider previous determinations of findings listed above.
- finding that no historic properties are present or likely to be present in the area of potential effect of the project;
- determination of eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places;
- determination of the project's effect on a historic property; and/or
- treatment plan to excavate or mitigate adverse effects of the project on a historic property.
- Determination of Eligibility. TxDOT-ENV shall provide the Tribe an opportunity to comment on determinations of eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places (under 36 CFR Part 60) for each Native American archeological site within the Tribe's Area of Concern that has not been determined to be culturally affiliated with another federally recognized tribe and will be affected by a proposed transportation activity. In the event that the Tribe objects within thirty (30) days of receipt to TxDOT-ENV's determination of eligibility for a Native American site, TxDOT-ENV shall review the documentation provided by the Tribe to support its objection and make a reasoned response to the Tribe. If the Tribe continues to object, TxDOT-ENV shall provide FHWA a copy of the documentation along with copies of the results of consultation with other consulting parties. FHWA shall review this documentation and:
- consult with the Tribe or the Keeper of the Register to resolve the objection; and
- notify all consulting parties of the outcome.
- Treatment: TxDOT-ENV shall provide the Tribe an opportunity to comment on TxDOT's treatment plan for any Native American historic property in the Tribe's Area of Concern that has not been determined to be culturally affiliated with another federally recognized tribe, as follows:
In the event that the Tribe objects to the treatment plan within thirty (30) days of receipt of the proposed treatment plan, TxDOT-ENV shall review the documentation provided by the Tribe to support its objection and make a reasoned response to the Tribe. If the Tribe continues to object, TxDOT-ENV shall provide FHWA a copy of the documentation along with copies of the results of consultation with all consulting parties. FHWA shall review this documentation and:
- Where feasible, the historic property will be avoided by the proposed transportation activity;
- Where avoidance is not feasible, treatment shall be carried out in accordance with the Archaeology and Historic Preservation: The Secretary of Interior's Standards and Guidelines. Treatment shall also:
- be commensurate with the significance of the historic property; and
- may include educational or public outreach efforts.
- consult with the Tribe to resolve the objection or with the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation; and
- notify all consulting parties of the outcome.
- Native American Graves. In the event that Native American burials that may be culturally affiliated with the Tribe are anticipated or discovered during archeological excavation or during construction of the project, TxDOT-ENV shall seek to avoid impacts to the site. If it is not feasible to avoid the site and the burials, TxDOT-ENV shall document why avoidance is not feasible, and:
- develop a treatment plan in accord with Article 9 above; and
- at the completion of the excavations, analysis, and reporting required by the treatment plan and TxDOT's Antiquities Permit:
- complete an inventory, as per 43 CFR §10.9, the regulations implementing NAGPRA;
- complete a Repatriation Agreement in consultation with the culturally affiliated tribe; and
- transfer custody of the objects to the agreed upon, proper recipient.
- During the excavation of any Native American graves, TxDOT shall also take measures to ensure:
- respectful, dignified treatment of burials at all times during excavation and analysis;
- security for the site and the graves to prevent vandalism when archeologists are not present at the site(s);
- no photographs are taken of human remains or open graves other than photo-documentation needed for recordation of the excavation;
- tours of the cemetery are given only if considered appropriate by the affiliated Tribe;
- off-site security for exhumed burials and funerary objects during and after excavation;
- opportunities are provided for the culturally affiliated tribe to visit the site and provide comments during archeological excavation and for the Tribe to perform appropriate ceremonies.
- Emergency Discovery Procedures. In the event of an emergency discovery of a Native American site after award of a construction contract, TxDOT shall:
- follow TxDOT-ENV's Emergency Discovery Guidelines (Attachment 2) which are incorporated into this agreement by reference;
- notify the Tribe of the finding by telecommunication of the find and invite them to visit the site with TxDOT-ENV; and
- notify the Tribe by fax of their determination of the need (or not) for further investigations. If further investigations are determined to be warranted, TxDOT-ENV shall provide the Tribe with a copy of the plan of those investigations by fax. The Tribe shall have one full business day to respond, unless otherwise specified. TxDOT-ENV shall be available to answer the Tribe's questions during that day. If the Tribe objects to the investigations, TxDOT-ENV shall provide FHWA a copy of the documentation along with copies of the results of consultation with all consulting parties. FHWA shall review this documentation and render its decision, notifying all parties of its decision.
- Amendment and Termination. Any party to this consultation agreement may request that it be amended, whereupon the parties shall consult to consider such amendment. Any party to this agreement may terminate it by providing thirty (30) days' written notice to the other parties, provided that the parties will consult during the period prior to the termination to seek agreement on amendments or other actions that would avoid termination. In the event of termination, the FHWA will comply with 36 CFR §§800.4-800.6.
- Severability. In the event any one or more of the provisions contained in this agreement shall for any reason, be held to be invalid, illegal, or unenforceable in any respect, such invalidity, illegality, or unenforceability shall not affect any other provision thereof and this agreement shall be construed as if such invalid, illegal, or unenforceable provision had never been contained herein.
- Signatory Warranty. The undersigned signatories represent and warrant that each has full and complete authority to enter into this contract on behalf of their organizations. These representations and warranties are made for the purpose of inducing the parties to enter into this contract.
FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION
Dan Reagan, P.E.
CADDO TRIBE OF OKLAHOMA
THE STATE OF TEXAS
Executed for the Executive Director and approved by the Texas Transportation Commission for the purpose and effect of activating and/or carrying out the orders, established policies or work programs heretofore approved and authorized by the Texas Transportation Commission.
Michael W. Behrens, PE.
Texas Department of Transportation
Attachment 1: Area of Concern for the Caddo Tribe of Oklahoma
ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS DIVISION
Cultural Resource Management
Emergency Discovery Guidelines
In the event of the discovery of archeological remains (broken historic pottery, stone tools, bone, etc.) encountered after the award of construction for transportation activities, Specification 7.17 of the Standard Specifications for Construction and Maintenance of Highways, Streets, and Bridges requires that construction cease in the area of the remains until steps to investigate and evaluate the find have been completed. Below are outlined the recommended steps to take when such remains are identified:
- The TxDOT district Construction Engineer or TxDOT's contractor shall notify the district Environmental Coordinator who will inform Cultural Resource Management section (CRM) in the Environmental Affairs Division (512 416-2631 or 512 416-2617). If necessary, fencing or other devices may be used to ensure avoidance.
- CRM shall investigate the find within one full business day of notification, unless otherwise specified.
- Upon receipt of notification, CRM shall notify the Division of Archeology, Texas Historical Commission (THC) and, for federal projects, the Federal Highway Administration by telecommunication of the potential find and invite them to accompany CRM staff to the site.
- CRM's visit to the site will be coordinated with the district Environmental Coordinator, our district point of contact.
- CRM will evaluate the need, or not, for further investigations based on their inspection of the find. CRM and district will jointly decide if on-site security is needed for the discovery. The district Environmental Coordinator shall be responsible for notification of the appropriate TxDOT personnel (e.g., Area Engineer, project manager, inspector, etc.). District personnel shall, in turn, be responsible for notification of appropriate construction personnel (contractor, subcontractor, utilities, etc.), and appropriate local government officials including local historic preservation offices, if any, about these decisions.
- If CRM determines that an unrecorded archeological site is present, they shall complete a State of Texas site form while at the site.
- If CRM determines that the site does not warrant further investigations, they will fax a letter to the THC with this recommendations and request THC=s concurrence with those recommendations. The letter will be sent within one full business day after return to headquarters. A copy of the letter shall be faxed to the district Environmental Coordinator. The THC shall have one full business day to respond, unless otherwise specified. During that day, CRM will be available to answer THC questions. No response from the THC within that period will be deemed to represent concurrence. If THC concurs, a copy of the THC letter shall be faxed to the district Environmental Coordinator who shall inform the Area Engineer that work may proceed.
- If CRM determines that the site warrants further investigation, the Environmental Coordinator will be notified by Group-Wise and by telephone. A plan for those investigations shall be developed within two full business days after return to headquarters, unless otherwise specified. The plan shall be reviewed by the district Environmental Coordinator during those two days. Upon completion of the plan, it must be reviewed and approved by the THC within one full business day. During that day, CRM will be available to answer THC questions. If the THC does not concur with the plan, CRM will re-negotiate the plan with the THC, or follow the stipulations of the Programmatic Agreement, as appropriate. If approved, the plan shall be implemented by the CRM or a qualified archeological contractor in accordance with the schedule contained in the plan upon approval of the plan by THC. Upon completion of the scope in the plan, the district Environmental Coordinator will be notified by CRM that construction may proceed.
back to top